This Spring, when we had tornadoes nearby that gave us straighline winds at 100 mph and there were some cosmetic damages to the house and shop at this little place here, one of the casualties was the screen/storm door we've had on our front door for almost 20 years. It got ripped open, and the closing mechanisms (top and bottom) were badly bent. One of the hinges was also damaged. So, our homeowners insurance approved us for a new one. Being set in my ways and if I like something I typically like it forever no matter what newer stuff comes out, we ordered an identical screen door to replace it. It took a while to arrive, and then it sat in the garage for a couple of weeks before DH decided it was time to remove the old one (we'd had that door locked shut for months since the storm in order to keep it from flapping) and install the new one.
That's actually not where this story really begins. For years, DH has off and on speculated if we should add a screen door to the door that sits between the garage and the mudroom. It is the door we use most often, and we've always thought, due to the location, and the ease of not having two doors to open just to get into and out of the house, that it didn't need a screen door. However, in the summer, since we don't have air conditioning, our house does get rather hot at times, and DH has wondered if having a screen door in that spot might allow more air flow through the mudroom and kitchen (and therefore into the rest of the house) by being able to open the regular door while still keeping out bugs (and critters). His thought was that with two huge north-facing garage doors open, that would let a whole bunch of coolish air into the garage, and with just a screen door between the garage and mudroom, the coolish air would get sucked into the house.
Being that money at this little place here nearly always has a better designated purpose than a full length screen door for a spot you usually don't put a screen door, we never bought one. But now, now we had a 'perfectly good' (if you don't need a closing mechanism, or mind one hinge being marked up from being pounded back into relative straightness) screen door for no cost. That 'perfectly good' door being the old one from the front door.
When he removed the broken one from the front of the house and installed the new perfect screen door, he decided to see if he could adjust the broken one to be straight enough to latch without having to be jimmied into position and then locked to keep it there. So he did some clamping and banging out in the shop, then brought the door into the garage, where he flipped it (having been a left hand swing at the front door and now needing to be a right hand swing to work in the garage where you came up the porch from the left side of the door) and screwed it into place.
Well, it fit the opening fine. But it didn't latch. Something about the flipping to reverse direction and the jamb of the existing garage/mudroom door he was trying to attach it to didn't quite work as well as he'd thought it would. After about three hours of fuc--- messing with it (now 10 p.m. when at 7 he'd thought it would be a 15 minute install) he called it quits for the night. Hopefully sleeping on it would provide the insight he needed in how to correct whatever the root of the problem was.
The next day was the one I left to go to Shipshewana with DD1, DD2 and the granddaughters. The door was hung in place, but didn't latch. Sometime after work that day, DH worked on it again. He came up with a solution. A little unorthodox (removing something on the frame usually considered necessary), but it did the trick. When I returned from Shipshewana, I was surprised and delighted to find a screen door between my mudroom and garage that latches without being locked!
Is it beautiful and undented and scratch free? No. Does it hang properly in the opening and latch closed easily? Yes. Does it have a closing mechanism that lets it open only so far and then slowly brings it closed again? Nope. Does it really need one in the location it's now in? We don't think so.
Most importantly, when you open the overhead garage doors and then open the door between the mudroom and the garage, does a cool breeze come into the mudroom and kitchen through the screen door? Oh heck yes, it does!
And, during the cooler months of the year, when we won't want to leave the solid door open so don't really need a screen door there, we'll just open the screen door all the way, and block it open resting flat on the garage wall (out of the way) so we won't need to open and close two doors all winter while going into or out of the mudroom from the garage. Brilliant!
We're really glad DH thought to try to salvage the broken door and see if it was usable in this space, where he'd thought a screen door might actually be beneficial, rather than just tossing it into the trash when he installed the replacement screen door. Kept it out of the landfill (or, at least, the parts that wouldn't have gone to the scrap metal pile) and fulfilled a need we weren't even totally sure we had.
Waste not, want not.
As a bonus, it makes a really cool 'snick' sound when it latches shut. Brings up childhood memories of running out screen doors belonging to our grandparents back in the day.